Half the minutes for the same morphology outcomes? Yes, please

We’ve talked before about dose, or how much of the “active ingredients” of therapy a child is getting. In a new study, researchers wanted to find out if the intensity of the dose within a single session affected outcomes. They tested two groups of preschoolers with developmental language disorder (DLD). For each child, the researchers chose two morphemes—one to treat and one to monitor without treatment. All children got Enhanced Conversational Recast* treatment, which calls for 24 unique recasts (correct clinician repetitions of the child's attempt to use their treated morpheme) while the child attends to the clinician. Half of the children had “sparse” sessions, where recasts were spread out over 30 minutes (0.8 recasts per minute). The other half had “dense” sessions, where recasts were crammed into only 15 minutes (1.6 recasts per minute).

14.png

After six weeks of daily sessions, both groups improved their average accuracy for their treated (but not their untreated) morphemes. The results weren’t significantly different across groups though—it didn’t matter whether children had sparse or dense sessions.

So for Enhanced Conversational Recast treatment, the dose of 24 unique recasts is crucial but the length of the session is not. The authors point out that this means we could split a pair of antsy kiddos seen together for 30 minutes into individual 15-minute sessions and likely see the same progress, as long as the dose number stays the same.

*For more on Enhanced Conversational Recast treatment see reviews here, here, and here

 **Also, read the comments below for a pro tip for implementing this from Dr. Plante!

Plante, E., Mettler, H. M., Tucci, A., & Vance, R. (2019). Maximizing treatment efficiency in developmental language disorder: Positive effects in half the time. American Journal of Speech-Language Pathology. doi:10.1044/2019_AJSLP-18-0285.